On an ordinary Tuesday, a few blocks from a local BurgerFi, the lunch rush looks like business as usual—kids munching fries, workers balancing trays, staff hustling. But zoom out, and the reality is far less simple. BurgerFi, the brand that once promised to reimagine the fast-casual burger joint, is fighting for survival after a bruising stretch. It’s not toast—at least not yet—but the kitchen’s definitely hotter than it’s ever been.
The Numbers Don’t Lie: BurgerFi’s Financial Squeeze
Let’s start with the headlines that made investors wince. BurgerFi International Inc., holding company for both BurgerFi and Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in September 2024. For the business curious, Chapter 11 doesn’t mean “shut the doors and switch off the fryers.” Think of it more as a corporate pit stop: legal cover to restructure debts and try to turn the ship before it sinks.
What led here? BurgerFi’s financials were feeling crispy for a while. Sales at existing stores dropped — down 13% in early 2024 if you’re tracking. Losses piled up every quarter, even when those losses narrowed slightly compared to full-scale pandemic chaos. Net losses kept stacking, eroding any confidence left among investors. At one point, the company’s stock price was swinging in the $1 range—a massive slide from pandemic-era highs.
When the numbers look this ugly for several quarters running, lenders and landlords start knocking, and even the most optimistic CEO starts talking about “streamlining” with a straight face.
How Does Chapter 11 Work for a Burger Chain?
Bankruptcy filings spook customers and franchisees alike—nobody wants to eat uncertainty with their cheeseburger. But Chapter 11 isn’t a death sentence. Instead, it’s a reorganizational move meant to buy time, cut dead weight, and renegotiate deals with creditors. BurgerFi’s play is to shed debt and dead-end obligations while keeping the grills hot at viable locations.
This has led to a high-stakes triage. The company’s plan: close underperforming stores, work with landlords to negotiate leases, and focus on stores still turning a profit. BurgerFi’s CEO, Carl Bachmann, framed it bluntly in a September press release: “This is not us giving up. It’s us resetting to get healthier and more competitive.”
Or as one franchisee put it to local reporters outside a recently closed store: “We’ll fight for every customer, but we can’t fight gravity on three years of negative sales.”
The Storefront Reality: Shrinking to Survive
This fight means a visible cutback across the BurgerFi system. By the middle of 2024, BurgerFi shuttered nine corporate stores and ten Anthony’s locations (the pizza sibling brand acquired in late 2021). Franchisees, too, are voting with their feet—outlets in places like Saratoga Springs and Colonie, New York, will lock their doors for good in December. You don’t need a spreadsheet to feel the contraction; empty storefronts do the talking.
Here’s the punchline: that leaves BurgerFi with 144 locations—still open as of fall 2024. On paper, that’s a decent footprint for a regional burger player. But it’s down meaningfully from the chain’s high mark. For context, some years ago, BurgerFi was pushing toward 200 units nationwide. Closing nearly ten percent of your restaurants in a single year sends a message—the sweet spot is “leaner and, hopefully, meaner.”
Still, contraction isn’t always defeat. Many well-known brands have pruned weak locations (remember Starbucks’ big cull in 2008 that didn’t kill the brand?). The trick is knowing which units to cut and how to support the survivors.
Franchisees in the Crosshairs and the Pain of Local Loss
If you want to see the real-life impact of these cuts, talk to local franchisees. Many put up savings and sweat equity to build a BurgerFi, banking on the promise of all-natural beef and millennial-friendly branding. When stores close, it’s personal—jobs lost, rents unpaid, and trust shaken.
Curiously, corporate is pushing to keep as many outlets open as possible, leaning into new franchise agreements even in 2024. But local owners usually make the final call, and some are simply walking away. The chain’s communication? “We’re aligned to right-size the system.” In plain English: fewer locations, betting the survivors will be healthier.
Where Things Stand: Still Flipping Burgers, But on a Short Leash
Stop by any of the 144 still-operating stores, and it won’t feel like a chain in free fall. Operations roll on—burgers grilled, fries served, shakes spinning. The company tells the public (and creditors) that every site is open and all jobs remain, at least for now.
But the tension is real. Every remaining store faces even more scrutiny on performance. Corporate is hounding for higher ticket averages and pushing “premium limited-time offers” to juice same-store sales. Franchisees face stricter standards; lease negotiations get fierce. Everyone is waiting to see if a tighter operation can finally swing into the black.
Meanwhile, BurgerFi continues to ink new franchise deals, focusing on select markets that show better promise (like the Southeast and suburban Texas). That’s a sign of confidence—or at least survival instinct. Franchise leads are still being pitched; the website flashes pitches for new partners, still hopeful for a rebound story.
The Economy Isn’t Helping—And Neither Are Rivals
Fast-casual burger joints don’t operate in a vacuum. Labor costs, ground beef prices, and lease rates keep rising. The burger market is, to put it nicely, oversaturated. Think Shake Shack, Smashburger, Five Guys, even McDonald’s throwing shade on every corner.
BurgerFi’s shtick—better quality for a bit more money—looks noble until inflation really bites. If your same-store sales are off by double digits and costs are rising, you feel the squeeze every shift. This puts huge pressure on store managers, especially in suburban and college town locations, to deliver more profit with less foot traffic.
Then there’s branding struggle. Post-pandemic, every restaurant is now an “experience.” BurgerFi tried everything—ghost kitchens, menu tweaks, new tech for app orders. Results? Mixed, at best. Some customers returned, but many drifted to cheaper or trendier rivals. The promise of “all-natural, never-ever beef” wears thin when your wallet is thinner.
Can BurgerFi’s Turnaround Plan Work?
Here’s the multi-million-dollar gamble: BurgerFi must stabilize financially, shore up cash flow, and—most importantly—reignite demand. The turnaround isn’t just about closing loss leaders. It’s about making the math finally work for both franchisee and corporate sides.
Key moves in the plan:
- Renegotiate debt for breathing room and lower interest payments
- Prioritize markets with higher sales per square foot
- Cut overhead where possible (think tighter shifts, leaner management, smaller marketing spends)
- Double down on higher-margin menu items—like specialty burgers and signature sides
- Keep the brand semi-visible with strategic expansion where it makes sense
This sounds straightforward, but execution is the hard part. Losing even 5-10% of your system can kill economies of scale. Lower volume spreads fixed costs across fewer stores. Landlords sometimes refuse to budge on terms, and lenders won’t fund endless losses.
On top of that, franchisee morale is battered. Recruiting new owners in a system going through Chapter 11 is a tough sell—unless you spin the story as “the brand is back, leaner, and poised for growth.” That’s a narrative we’ve seen before (see: Quiznos, minus the fiery crash). Sometimes, double-down gets you a lifeline, sometimes just more debt.
To keep up with news on business turnarounds and bankruptcy strategy, check out this resource for more practical breakdowns.
What Does All This Mean for Customers—and the Brand?
If you’re a burger fan, what changes? For now, not much day-to-day. BurgerFi’s locations remain open—your cheeseburger, urban fries, and custard shakes are still available. Some cities have lost their local outlet, but the burger itself isn’t disappearing from the country’s culinary map.
But there’s no shortage of risk ahead. Brand reputation can suffer when “bankruptcy” trends in your region. New store growth in key cities remains slow, as the company tries to protect what’s left.
Investors, meanwhile, are in “watch and wait” mode. As one industry analyst put it: “They’re one modest hit away from stability—or from another round of cuts.” If sales keep lagging and the economy worsens, expect even more closures. If a new menu hits home and costs come down? The tables could turn.
BurgerFi’s Story: Not Finished, But Definitely at a Crossroads
To sum up: BurgerFi is not out of business. But it is in a critical, no-room-for-error stretch. Chapter 11 bankruptcy doesn’t mean “lights out”—it’s a chance at a second act, provided the new script lands with customers, investors, and franchisees.
We’ve seen big brands bounce back with sharper focus and new energy. But we’ve also seen plenty flame out. BurgerFi is still serving burgers, but the real meal now is survival. If you’re betting on them, track cash flow, sales comps, and franchisee sentiment—not just spin.
One last note—watching everyday businesses slog through rough patches is instructive for entrepreneurs. Adapt fast, cut sooner than you want, and never wait for the room to empty before you move to a better one. On BurgerFi’s menu in 2024? Fewer locations, tighter numbers, and a hope that the grill keeps going. Reliability compounds, even in a burger joint.
Also Read:
