It’s Tuesday night at a Frisch’s Big Boy by the interstate. The neon Big Boy statue stands sentry, grinning into the dusk. Inside, there’s a clink of forks, a jukebox glow, and someone’s grandparent debating the merits of a hot fudge cake versus a fish sandwich. But lately, scenes like this are vanishing across Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana. If you’ve driven by a closed Frisch’s in the last few months, you’ve probably wondered: Is Frisch’s Big Boy going out of business?
The short answer is “No—but almost.” Frisch’s isn’t disappearing entirely, but it’s shrunk fast, battered by evictions, lawsuits, and past mistakes. Think fewer locations, fewer staff, and a lot more stress in the C-suite. Let’s unravel what’s happened, what’s left, and why this nearly century-old brand isn’t ready for the graveyard—at least not yet.
Background and Context: A Big Boy History (with Bumps)
Frisch’s Big Boy isn’t just another roadside burger joint. Opened in Cincinnati in 1946, it popularized drive-in dining, carhops, and, honestly, that double-decker burger people still order “just like Grandpa did.” At its peak, it commanded over 100 units across the Midwest, feeding generations with onion rings and nostalgia.
But here’s where the story sours. In 2015, after decades as a local stalwart, Frisch’s was scooped up by NRD Capital, a private equity firm out of Atlanta. The deal included a much-hyped sale-leaseback: Frisch’s sold off most of its restaurant real estate to an outside landlord (NNN REIT LP), getting a burst of cash but handing its fate to lease contracts. For a while, this move padded the books. Over time, though, it would become the chain’s Achilles’ heel.
Challenges Faced by Frisch’s Big Boy: When the Bill Comes Due
Fast-forward to late 2024, and things look grim. Frisch’s finds itself underwater, struggling to pay steep rents on properties it no longer owns, thanks to that 2015 deal. Lease payments keep coming; burger orders slow. Margins sputter. Within just months, the chain racks up overdue balances. Vendors start grumbling about unpaid invoices—not just for ketchup, but core supplies. Around the same time, lawsuits start stacking up from suppliers and partners left hanging.
The numbers paint a brutal picture: Over $1 million in rent owed across multiple states. Vendors file claims for tens of thousands. Store managers field customer questions about closing, while back-office staff scramble to keep the lights on—sometimes literally. The Big Boy isn’t alone: Restaurant chains nationwide are grappling with post-pandemic costs, but Frisch’s story has its own unlucky flavor.
Impact of Evictions and Closures: From Main Street to Empty Lots
By October 2024, the reckoning arrives. NNN REIT LP, perceiving Frisch’s as a chronic late-payer, files eviction notices for more than a dozen locations in Greater Cincinnati alone. One by one, stores go dark. By year’s end, at least twenty Frisch’s units shutter, mostly in Ohio but with a few in Kentucky and Indiana. The Big Boy statues? Some stand forlorn behind locked doors, neighborhood landmarks now looking a little more like relics.
Some closures are abrupt—employees find out via text or on a Monday morning. Others linger weeks in limbo, with regulars showing up to “closed permanently” signs. Pending eviction hearings threaten even more stores, so the final tally may grow. The sweet spot (if you can call it that) is this: over 20 closures since October 2024, wiping out roughly a third of the pre-crisis footprint.
The story on the ground is tough. Staffers in their fifties scramble for last paychecks. Loyal customers campaign online to “Save Our Frisch’s.” Rival chain managers quietly poach kitchen talent. In small towns, losing a Frisch’s is more than losing a burger—it’s losing a gathering place, sometimes the only late-night option for miles.
Current Operations: What’s Left in the Big Boy Kingdom?
Here’s where things get complicated but not hopeless. After the eviction wave, Frisch’s limps into 2025 with just 31 locations operating—down from over 100 a decade before. The remaining stores cluster in Indiana, Ohio, and Kentucky. A few franchises outside this geography weather the storm, but most company-owned locations are gone or hanging by a thread.
A new management team steps in—literally, since most of the brand’s leaders are longtime Frisch’s staffers who orchestrated a “takeback” of the company from NRD Capital in November 2024. It’s a senior manager-led reboot, low on capital but high on insider grit. Their first moves? Scrub underperforming stores, safeguard cash, keep the favorites (Big Boy Combo, breakfast buffet) alive, and rebuild trust with staff and suppliers.
You won’t find splashy marketing or grand “comeback” ads. The focus is practical: plug holes, preserve the core, and weather more landlord challenges. They’re transparent, telling local news, “Not every unit is viable. We’re investing in what can win.”
Ownership and Management: From Boardroom Drama to Blue-Collar Reboot
November 2024 marks a turning point when a group of Frisch’s “lifers”—mid-level managers, area GMs, and a few finance folks—band together to buy out the business. No private equity razzle-dazzle here; just burger folks fighting for their jobs and hometown pride.
Their takeover signals a vibe shift. They openly admit the old model can’t work: too many locations, too much overhead, zero room for error. The new leadership is scrappy and streetwise. “Selective investment is the name of the game,” says one exec. The plan? Triage the patched-up ship, pick stores in robust trade areas, and negotiate better lease terms (or buy back some real estate).
They’re prioritizing three fixes:
1. Negotiate new deals with landlords to lower risk.
2. Give stores operational freedom and local flavor.
3. Rebuild the supply chain so food actually shows up on time and on budget.
Anyone expecting a miracle overnight will be disappointed. But if you like gritty turnarounds that favor reality over hype, this is a textbook example in the making.
Future Prospects: Can Big Boy Get His Groove Back?
Let’s be honest: Not every legacy brand claws its way out of a nosedive. The Frisch’s formula, though, still has some muscle. The Buffett-style breakfast, the recognizable mascot, and—yes—the nostalgia factor, all give it brand equity that’s tricky to replicate. Even post-crisis, the Big Boy still means something in Cincinnati, Louisville, and pockets of Indiana.
The new management’s theory? Cut to a healthy core, focus obsessively on profitable units, and invest in the few locations with reinvention potential. The math is simple: keep stores full, staff paid, and landlords off your back. Selective growth—not wild new expansion—sets the pace.
But let’s not sugarcoat the challenges. The company faces intense competition, lingering legal claims, skeptical landlords, and customers who can be fickle (especially when lunch is $12+). Throw in high labor costs and tighter supplies, and the comeback trail is rough.
There’s reason for cautious optimism, though. Other battered chains—like Steak ‘n Shake and Friendly’s—have stabilized after brutal downsizing. Local operators with skin in the game tend to fight harder and hustle smarter. If the new team can boost customer frequency (even a ~10% jump), keep expenses under control, and spark some hometown buzz, the odds improve.
For anyone trying to keep up on battered-but-not-beaten brands, it pays to watch moves like this. See which units get a mini-remodel, which ones add drive-thru upgrades, and how the menu adapts (Will the breakfast bar make a full comeback?). Local press and business analysts at sites like The Business Back are tracking every twist—and for operators in other industries, these moves are solid case studies in crisis management, not just cautionary tales.
Conclusion: Not Gone, Just Seriously Slimmed Down
Frisch’s Big Boy has stared down one of its toughest eras—sudden closures, big legal fights, landlords banging down the door, and a cloud of uncertainty that would spook any management team. “Are they going out of business?” is a fair question, and a year ago, the answer almost flipped to “yes.” But here we are: fewer stores, new local leaders, and a business model built around only the strongest units.
It’d be foolish to predict a roaring comeback, but equally rash to count this brand out. At the moment, the game plan is survival over spectacle, reliability above risky bets. If Big Boy’s leaders can keep what’s left thriving, out-hustle the legal headaches, and remind customers why the place matters, maybe—just maybe—there’s another decade in the tank.
Now, if you’re itching for a comeback story or want to avoid your own business growing too fast for its britches, Frisch’s is proof that scale cuts both ways. Sometimes shrinking is the only path to longevity. For burger fans and business-watchers alike, the Big Boy saga is unfinished—and still flipping patties in the heartland, one order at a time.
Also Read:
