On an overcast Tuesday in San Antonio, a “Store Closing—Everything Must Go!” banner flapped outside a Popshelf. Shoppers drifted in, hunting for 30% discounts on candles and wall art. Some clearly knew the drill: liquidation means bargains, not a goodbye to the whole chain. It’s the same playbook from the likes of Bed Bath & Beyond, just less drastic. Popshelf is *not* disappearing—just trimming its sails as the winds have shifted.
Meet Popshelf—Dollar General’s Wild Card
If you haven’t walked into a Popshelf, imagine Dollar General’s cheerful, younger sibling who discovered Pinterest. Since its 2020 debut, Popshelf courted budget-minded suburbanites, pitching $1-$5 home décor, kitchen gadgets, crafts, party supplies, and more. The stores look brighter than the average dollar shop, with an air of, “Hey, spend on the fun stuff—leave bread and milk to the big guys.”
At one point in 2023, Dollar General executives talked up Popshelf like it was their breakout star. The plan? To open 1,000 stores by 2025; a shiny goal. But retail, as we know, is a game where optimism is forced to wrestle the scoreboard.
Why the Sudden Shrinking Act?
So what happened? The short answer: Americans started tightening their purses. Discretionary spending—translation: all the little non-essentials you didn’t plan on—slowed down. In 2024, shoppers flocked to the basics (“food, gas, and rent, if I’m lucky”), not ceramic pumpkins or faux orchids.
Dollar General’s CEO, Todd Vasos, put it plainly: “The discretionary side just didn’t bounce back.” That’s corporate code for: customers have bigger worries than table runners and scented candles. Even Popshelf’s attractive price tags weren’t always enough.
Competition played a nasty hand, too. Off-price chains (think HomeGoods, Five Below, even Walmart’s new budget décor aisles) stepped up their game. Suddenly, Popshelf found itself squeezed from above—chains with deeper pockets—and below, by dollar stores embracing more playful home lines.
Dollar General, famous for running lean, saw the writing on the wall. A strategic review kicked off in late 2024. By March 2025, the verdict came down: shrink to survive—keep the winners, shut or “flip” the laggards.
Just How Many Popshelf Stores Are Closing?
Here’s where numbers matter, so let’s keep it sharp. Out of Popshelf’s 231 locations, Dollar General announced 45 store closures and another 6 conversions—meaning around 20-22% are leaving the Popshelf club, and will either shutter or become regular Dollar General stores. The store count drops from 231 to roughly 180 by mid-2025. One out of every five Popshelfs will vanish. If you like percentages: that’s a 20% reset, not a disappearing act.
Some closures hit specific markets harder. San Antonio, for example, is set to lose both existing Popshelf stores. Liquidation signs are up, with customers snagging last-minute deals. The message is clear: not every town could sustain the Popshelf experiment.
Those six conversions? They’re not going dark, just swapping Popshelf’s purple-and-pastel branding for the familiar yellow and black of Dollar General. Blink and you might not know the difference, until you’re hunting bath bombs and find laundry detergent instead.
A Pause on Growth, Not a Full Retreat
If you thought expansion plans halted overnight, you’d be right. Dollar General hit the brakes hard—no more new Popshelf stores are opening in 2025. In fact, that pause actually began in late 2024, when sales started flatlining. The company focused on maximizing what already existed, rather than throwing good money (and expensive leases) at uncertain locations.
Existing stores won’t all look the same next year. The sweet spot is this: keep the proven performers, get ruthless about laggards, and keep an agile hand on the real estate till the economy perks up. “We’re not afraid to cut and run,” one district manager told me, “if it keeps the whole brand stronger nationwide.”
That’s the street-smart version of what Dollar General execs call “a disciplined, data-driven approach.” Less poetic, but money talks. And staying alive means making uncomfortable decisions when the numbers demand it.
So Is Popshelf Dying? Here’s Why Not
For all the doom-and-gloom chatter on business forums, Popshelf isn’t vanishing. The trimmed portfolio will be tight—just under 180 locations—but that’s still a real presence for a three-year-old idea.
Dollar General’s leadership isn’t moping. Instead, public statements are all about “innovation,” “refreshed product assortments,” and “improving store experience.” It sounds corporate, but there’s substance there. Execs spotlight double-digit sales growth at the best Popshelf sites, usually in higher-income suburbs or college towns with steady foot traffic.
And sales aren’t universally bleak; plenty of Popshelfs are hitting 15-20% year-over-year growth. In a world where grocery is flat and basic retail struggles, those numbers matter. If you run a chain and some stores are outpacing everything else, you invest in that formula. The closures are really a way to stop draining cash with the weakest links (think: land five recurring clients at ~$300/month and you’ve built an $18k baseline before lunch—reliability compounds).
Some changes should make shops more inviting, too. The focus is moving toward curated “mini moments” and cross-merchandising—pop-up feel, fresh displays, and limited-time finds.
For side hustlers and store managers alike, it’s a signal worth reading: Sometimes “scaling back” is really code for “tightening up your offer for the people who actually want it, and dumping the extras.” It’s lean retail, done with an eye on profitability, not ego.
What This Means for the Popshelf Customer and Crew
If you’re a regular Popshelf fan, you might lose your local store, but the chain isn’t vanishing. Odds are, the nearest surviving location will look a touch nicer, better stocked, and more focused. Smaller footprint, but higher average sales per shop—that’s the strategy.
Front-line staff aren’t immune to the shakeup. Closures always sting, with jobs sometimes shifted and sometimes cut. But a number of workers will have the option to transfer to nearby Dollar General stores. In practice? Not every commute will work out, but some jobs get saved. For Dollar General (and Popshelf), churn has always been a fact of life—across most retail, turnover rates in the high 30% are par for the course.
For the small business crowd, there’s a lesson here: keep your best sellers front and center, and don’t wait for a full collapse before you prune what’s dragging you down.
Dollar General’s Long Game: Survive First, Innovate Second
It’s easy to poke fun at “focus on the core business” as a buzzword, but it’s exactly what Dollar General is doing. By scaling back Popshelf, they’re not slinking into the shadows—they’re simply allocating resources where the returns are proven. In business, that kind of discipline is pure staying power.
To keep Popshelf relevant, new in-store experiences and flashy displays are in the pipeline. Each remaining Popshelf is being asked to experiment—lure in that millennial mom or crafty TikTokber with food tastings, DIY kits, and hyperlocal product drops. It’s a little “Target Lite,” but fits the Popshelf mold.
Dollar General isn’t afraid of swing-and-miss moments. “Retail’s about testing, doubling down on winners, and moving on from duds,” as one regional leader told us. There’s no shortage of optimism from the top, but also a realistic grasp of how tough it is to get suburban discretionary spenders off the couch in 2025.
For you, the punchline is straightforward: Businesses at large grow through *profitable* experimentation, not reckless expansion.
What’s Next? Popshelf’s Future Is Streamlined, Not Out
Here’s where real-world grit beats wishful thinking. Popshelf is sticking around, not pretending every single location deserves to survive. By being ruthless about store-by-store performance, Dollar General gives the brand its best shot at real, compound growth—maybe not overnight, but steady.
There’s a solid chance more store flips or closures could follow. This is less of a “last gasp” and more of an “earn every dollar twice before you spend it” moment across big retail. If you want to keep tabs on how aggressive brand pivots play out, bookmark a sober-eyed business site like The Business Back.
Meanwhile, watch for pops of success: Some Popshelf stores, especially in Texas, Georgia, and the Carolinas, are holding strong and even picking up new customers disillusioned with crowded big-box aisles. The market will reward places that earn their keep.
Survival here isn’t glamorous; it’s pragmatic. And that’s retail in a nutshell—focus on the profitable core, ruthlessly kill the duds, and make just enough room for whatever experiment could be the next breakout.
Takeaways: Popshelf Isn’t Done. It’s Just Growing Up
To wrap with a reality check: Popshelf is cutting back, halting new locations (for now), closing underperformers, and doubling down on stores that work. Parent company Dollar General is squeezing every lesson it can from this “retail lab,” and betting that a sharp focus on what moves will outlast another cycle of shaky spending.
If you run a business—or just like peeking behind the curtain—here’s the heart of it: Survival isn’t about size, but about speed and focus. And while Popshelf may be smaller on the outside next quarter, the experiment isn’t over. Sometimes, the best business move is less about being everywhere, and more about being *essential* somewhere.
So next time you spot a Popshelf closing sign, don’t read it as a eulogy—read it as a recalibration. In retail and in life, sometimes you shed a few pounds to run further.
Also Read:
